The Case for Small Government

A Libertarian Perspective on Economic and Social Policy

April 09, 2006

Immigration "Reform"

Congress appears to have reached an impasse in its attempt to “reform” U.S. immigration law. This time-out is a good occasion to ask what changes, if anything, might be desirable.

Illegal immigration results from two factors: restrictions on legal immigration, and the gap between economic opportunities available in the U.S. relative to poorer countries. These gaps include both differences in wages as well as differences in government benefits.

Reducing illegal immigration, therefore, requires one of the following steps: fewer barriers to legal immigration; more effective barriers to illegal immigration; or a smaller gap between economic opportunities here and elsewhere.

I personally favor expanded opportunities for legal immigration, even to the point of open borders. Political support for even mild relaxation in immigration restrictions appears wanting, however. I also favor reducing the generosity of “welfare” policies in the U.S., although I do not think the “welfare” magnet is the main reason for illegal immigration.

Enhanced border controls or employers sanctions will not reduce illegal immigration substantially, at least not without huge costs. Moreover, there is little support for the draconian measures that might significantly reduce the inflow.

And anything the U.S. might do to enhance economic growth elsewhere (such as promoting free trade) is likely to take decades rather than years.

The prospects for reducing illegal immigration are therefore bleak. So, what should Congress do?

Probably nothing. Most of what has been proposed will have little effect, and some “reforms” might generate substantial costs (e.g., increased employer sanctions). Amnesties that impose few restrictions on illegal immigrants will bring some of them above ground, but this approach also might generate increased interest in immigration. And the amnesties being proposed are bureaucratic nightmares that few illegal immigrants will find attractive in any case.

The only proposal that is in the right direction is the guest worker program proposed by President Bush. Unfortunately, this proposal has not received strong support.

16 Comments:

At 9:22 PM, Blogger JasonSpalding said...

Cheap labor at all costs? We have seen in France what happens.

 
At 10:11 PM, Blogger Publius said...

The majority of Americans do not favor granting these 11 million people amnesty and yet the Senate is trying to go against their wishes. And although there is a deep and even divide on the issue of a guest worker program, look how poorly it has worked in France and Germany. The rioters in France were mostly Muslim guest workers and I have personally seen how poorly it works in Germany where millions of Turks have entered Germany and it has created a deep and volatile divide.
And, shouldn’t you have also added the racist remark that the U.S. needs a guest worker program because white and black people won’t do these jobs but Hispanics will?

 
At 10:25 PM, Anonymous Anonymous said...

"Congress appears to have reached an impasse"

Gridlock is good.

Almost everything bill our congress passes is, on net, a negative.

One can't help but think our gov't is getting bigger and bigger and worse and worse with each and every passing year. Are we on a one-way trip away from small government?

 
At 1:25 AM, Anonymous Anonymous said...

I agree wholeheartedly that one of the major causes of illegal immigration is restrictions on legal immigration. As an immigration lawyer, I am keenly aware of the restrictions in current law that make it extremely difficult, if not impossible, for a poor person from Mexico to enter the US legally to find work. Even lawful permant residents of the US (people with with green cards) now have to wait six to eight years to bring their spouses and children to join them.

 
At 5:05 AM, Blogger Al Brown said...

If Mexico didn't exist at all and no foreign labor was available, those jobs would be performed by Americans. Higher wages might need to be paid, some of those jobs woudn't be viable or some would be automated. In any case, the economy would rebalance as it always does.

The key to reforming the employment situation is stop encumbering "legitimate" labor with all the costs of regulation, unemployment insurance, social security contributions, disability insurance and high income taxes. Of course any labor that can avoid those costs is going to try to get in. They become that much more competitive.

We need to stop pushing the costs of our social goals onto employers and pay for them ourselves or rethink them.

Removing that pressure will decrease illegal immigration. A guest worker program is a good idea too. I say we could require people learn about our system, language and values to qualify for that program and limit their stay.

As far as everyone that has already been here for a long time, lets grandfather them in and give them a path to citizenship. But we should straighten things out also so people can come here without risking their lives and we can have greater confidence about our borders (ok, so that would be a complete illusion).

 
At 11:49 AM, Anonymous Anonymous said...

Thanks for your wonderful blog. I've learned alot about california car insurance
here. I've got a little site which contains info about california car insurance , as well
as a few other things. Please stop by
Thanks

 
At 2:56 AM, Anonymous Anonymous said...

Very cool design! Useful information. Go on! »

 
At 10:26 PM, Anonymous Anonymous said...

...please where can I buy a unicorn?

 
At 11:41 AM, Anonymous Anonymous said...

su pensamiento es magnГ­fico http://nuevascarreras.com/cialis/ cialis dosis Caratteristiche:) cialis precio argentina diggbjyetp [url=http://www.mister-wong.es/user/COMPRARCIALIS/comprar-viagra/]comprar viagra[/url]

 
At 5:06 PM, Anonymous Anonymous said...

[url=http://alanizvideos.com/members/crestor-update-march-2006-35/default.aspx]crestor update march 2006[/url] [url=http://centrocs.activclient.com/members/Emsam-and-edema-87/default.aspx]Emsam and edema[/url]
discount generic viagra soft tabs losing weight after stop taking celexa
http://buhain.com:8081/cs/members/king-soopers-pharmacy-denver-23/default.aspx order ultram cod
[url=http://dynamicwork.co.uk/members/zoloft-fatigue-side-effect-tired-72/default.aspx]zoloft fatigue side effect tired[/url] [url=http://centrocs.activclient.com/members/zyban-erfahrung-39/default.aspx]zyban erfahrung[/url]
publix pharmacy blog Celexa chest pain and chest burn
http://mygreencasa.net/members/2737-amerimedrx-retin-viagra-18/default.aspx does viagra work for mental ed
tamiflu indications limitations google4534553453322

 
At 11:38 AM, Anonymous Anonymous said...

Hello! Can you tell me how i can register mail at google [url=http://google.com]google[/url] http://google.com

 
At 7:31 AM, Anonymous Anonymous said...

[url=http://newloans.skachatnow.co.cc/high-loan-school.php]high loan school[/url]
http://loanstoday.skachatnow.co.cc/government-loan-for-new-business.php - government loan for new business
[url=http://fastloans.skachatnow.co.cc/fast-easy-payday-loan.php]fast easy payday loan[/url]
[url=http://fastloans.skachatnow.co.cc/texas-savings-and-loan-board.php]texas savings and loan board[/url]
http://getloan.skachatnow.co.cc/american-express-cash-advance.php - american express cash advance
[url=http://loanstoday.skachatnow.co.cc/calculator-loan-repayment.php]calculator loan repayment[/url]
[url=http://newloans.skachatnow.co.cc/free-loan-calculator-australia.php]free loan calculator australia[/url]
http://newloans.skachatnow.co.cc/lead-loan-mortgage-source.php - lead loan mortgage source
[url=http://newloans.skachatnow.co.cc/intitle-lead-loan-mortgage.php]intitle lead loan mortgage[/url]
[url=http://fastloans.skachatnow.co.cc/city-in-kansas-loan-mortgage-refinance.php]city in kansas loan mortgage refinance[/url]

 
At 3:19 PM, Anonymous Anonymous said...

Company Voluntary Arrangement CVA for a company is not an easy way out of debts, contrary to popular belief. However, there are also significant loopholes that will still allow the Inland Revenue and Customs and Excise to collect tax bills, even if a CVA for your company is filed and discharged. You need to sit down with an insolvency auditor or a solvency practitioner for a free consultation or call our helpline for free, 0800 24 0800.
Company Voluntary Arrangement

 
At 8:31 AM, Blogger Maria said...

The ideal primary teaching resource should contain a variety of useful features. High quality teaching resources can be the difference between a constructive, attentive and content classroom and an unproductive and idle one.
Primary Teaching Resources

 
At 11:52 AM, Blogger Moe Nawaz said...

UK Advice, nationally recognised as a business insolvency and business liquidation helper for business owners and company directors in UK, we arrange a meeting to your office or any place of work at no cost to you. Contact us today at our business liquidation helpline for free at 0800 24 0800.
Business Insolvency
Business Liquidation
Business Bankruptcy
Business Insolvency
Company Insolvency
Company Liquidation
Business Bankruptcy
Winding Up Petition
Company Debts
Pre Pack Administration
Business Debts
Insolvency Offices
Insolvency Auditor
Company Voluntary Arrangement
Birmingham Insolvency
London Insolvency
Manchester Insolvency

 
At 3:28 PM, Blogger Moe Nawaz said...

I like your post, the information in your post is quite good :), nice.. Thanks a lot... keep sharing:)
Mastermind Groups
Mastermind Coach
Mastermind Strategist
Time Management Skills
Business Growth Strategy
What is Mastermind Group
Why Join Mastermind Group
Mastermind Group Benefits
Business Growth Products
Business Coaching
Business Ideas
Business Coach
Business Mentor
Brand Strategist
Business Success Stories
Innovation Strategist
Business Growth Strategy
Business Success Stories

 

Post a Comment

<< Home